See Gallery
Papa Johns Pizza

Papa Johns Pizza Verified by Yext

3.9

(211 Reviews)

Write a Review

Listed In: Pizza Place

At Papa Johns Pizza in Athens, AL, itโ€™s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Athens pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Athens… Read more

3.9

211 Reviews

Write a Review
Krystal Willis

By Krystal Willis on October 8, 2026 Verified by Google

First time eating at this location. Just grabbed something while in the area... Just know, I will never eat here again. The pizza was DISGUSTING.. We ordered 2. Took bites if ONE slice and threw BOTH of them away... the cinnamon things was just bread no icing on top or on the side.

Jan

By Jan on August 2, 2026 Verified by Google

We ordered a pizza with the works. It was dry and barely had any sauce or any tast. When I called to complain, I spoke to someone who claimed to be the manager. She said her name was Jill. She became defensive and did not even apologize for the bad experience. As for as managers go, Papa John's is getting the bottom of the barrel! I also reported it to the home office. Don't waste your money!!! There are better places to eat!

CW Kennedy

By CW Kennedy on March 15, 2026 Verified by Google

Papa Johns advertised the "Super Hawaiian". The picture that they used looked so good, I ordered it.
What I got was a regular Hawaiian pizza. When I asked the cashier about how plain it looked, she said it was the Super Hawaiian.
They need to make their food look like what they advertise, otherwise it is false advertising.
Their crust is "too wide", meaning they do not put enough ingredients on it to take our all of the way out to the edge or atleast close to the edge and it definitely doesn't match the pictures.

Alyssa martines

By Alyssa martines on December 14, 2025 Verified by Google

My kids love Papa Johnโ€™s. This location is always on time with fresh and yummy pizza. No complaints from the kids. The only thing I would improve is sometimes the orders do not have what was asked for. Other than that this place is great! We also use the Papa dough which adds up with every purchase. It helps keep the price affordable for us.

Zonie Thompson

By Zonie Thompson on August 26, 2024 Verified by Google

Always have a great experience ordering with this location. Our order is always right, made quickly, and the employees are always professional and friendly.

Showing the overall rating from Google. Load more reviews to see individual Google reviews.

Powered by Opio

Papa Johns Pizza 3.9 out of 5.0 based on 211 user reviews.

Papa Johns Pizza
916 US Highway 72, Athens, AL
Get Directions

Additional Business Details

Business Hours

M-Sa 10am-midnight, Su 11am-11pm

Accepted Payments

American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Contactless, DEBITCARD, Discover, MasterCard, PayPal, Samsung Pay, Visa

Services

delivery, takeout, order ahead, dinner, lunch, dessert

Listing data provided by Yext

Similar Businesses See All

Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut

229 French Farms Blvd, Ste A, Athens, AL (1 Km Away)

0.0

(0 Reviews)

Domino's Pizza

Domino's Pizza

119 Highway 31 S, Athens, AL (2 Km Away)

0.0

(0 Reviews)

Village Pizza

Village Pizza

15728 E Limestone Rd, Athens, AL (12 Km Away)

0.0

(0 Reviews)

Business Claimed Update your Business

Report Incorrect Data Make an Update