By Lesley Lane on October 24, 2026 Verified by Google

Edit: I’m not very heart broken anymore in regards to my review below. I reached out to the owner and received a lackluster, bitter, uncaring email, it reminded me of the wings I had the other night. So I am here to clarify my review, this is not the first time the wings at the Jug Handle Inn have let me down. Since I had them for the first time in 2023, the quality dipped off drastically.

I was asked to provide some feedback to the business to keep future customers in the door. Truth be told customers at the Jug are long standing loyal ones. I doubt there will be new customers. I had this to say: My advice would be to be more consistent and keep up the quality you once had. It was there. I did not even mind the ridiculous price I payed for the wings last night because I told my boyfriend 'It's the Jug, they are hard working, give them our money' and then we get the quality of people who do not care. It is a shame.

ORIGINAL REVIEW: I am heart broken to write this review. The first time my boyfriend brought my here I said word for word, "These are the best wings I've ever had!". Last night we had them, and they were just awful. Just awful. Sooooo far from what they used to be!! The wings tasted like they just do not care anymore. Like they are okay being mediocre. The wings were soggy, chewy and had this weird rancid taste. On top of that they charge extra for rach/ bleu cheese (which is not the problem) but if you are charging at least get the customer's order correct. I ordered ranch and they gave me this disgusting bleu cheese! I am beyond sad. What happened to the pride here? $23.61 for 10 terrible wings, bleu cheese I did not want, and warm celery. Goodbye Jug, I will miss the old you...

By cynthia welsh on July 10, 2026 Verified by Google

I ordered 10 wings w/ blue cheese, celery & carrots, an Ital. hoagie & a side salad without cucumbers to go. $50!!! These used to be my FAVORITE wings. WTH???
I was terribly disappointed. The wings were just ok & the hoagie was not horrible. I paid 8.99 though for a .25 handful of lettuce & 1/2 a sliced tomato(that was all that was in the salad). 9 dollars for .50 worth of salad. They upcharged me for the limp, funky celery & carrots and tacked on a takeout fee (even tho we tipped). You carried it from the kitchen several feet. I know its only a buck, fifty but seriously? I was a waitress, so I get it...but what's with the nickel & diming people to death for the veg? 15 mins. after eating, I was in the bathroom & it was not just to wash up.
So. Very. Disappointed.

By MR FIX IT on June 28, 2026 Verified by Google

I use the love this Place.During Covid I always picked up wings a few times a week.They were always fresh,cooked perfectly and you couldn't get better anywhere.Lately I don't know what's going on but today I also got a burger fries and 10 wings mild and 20 hot.The burger and fries was pretty good cooked right fries fresh so far happy then comes the wings Burnt,Dry, Virtually no sauce except for a spoonful at the bottom.I think they fried these about 2-3 times .This has happened on three other occasions out of five orders You look at the wings people in there are eating you see they are cooked beautiful,juicy,covered in sauce with the extra breading falling all over.zthsts the wings I love.Sadly it appears when you take your order out they give you old refried wings that are inedible. sorry I'm done.I don't mind paying for good food.I always tip the person who gets my order too.I always give places extra chances because I understand no one is perfect but this Appears to be what they do with orders you don't see until you get home I was gonna look but was tired.Had I Looked I wouldn't of nicely said I'd like my $80 bucks back because. these wings are older that the Township itself.

By Jennifer Wexler on June 23, 2026 Verified by Google

We came for the wings after hearing they're the best around. Did not disappoint. We tried the Tony Bruno wings and were blown away. The sauce was sweet, tangy, and garlicky. The wings were nice and crispy. We also tried a burger between 2 grilled cheese sandwiches that was great. We'll definitely be back.

By Damian Reyes on November 21, 2025 Verified by Google

Met up with friends at the Jughandle Inn — first time back since my 20s, and it’s pretty much how I remembered it. We went on a Friday night and it was packed with loud music and that classic “town bar” vibe, even though it’s off on the outskirts by a major NJ highway. We ordered two sets of wings (garlic parmesan and honey hot), and they were fantastic — big, meaty, full of flavor, and they leave the tips on. A little pricey but worth it. Good beer selection too, with local brews alongside classics like Miller Lite and Coors Light. I also tried the Italian chicken sandwich, loaded with diced chicken, spinach, and melted cheese on a toasted roll. You can choose chips or upgrade to fries or tots. The sweet potato fries with honey (or honey hot) dip were excellent. Only downside: you aren’t assigned a dedicated server, so we found ourselves getting overlooked at times when trying to order drinks or get refills. Between the crowd and loud music, I felt like I was yelling all night. Still, the staff is friendly and the food is great.