By Rhonda Kinsey on July 19, 2026 Verified by Google

I'm surprised this place isn't busier. It does seem a little bit out of the way though. The pretzel bites are the best I've ever had. My husband and I both feel their pizza is the best we've had since moving to Punta Gorda. The staff are very friendly and attentive. I think people should definitely check out this restaurant. They'll enjoy it!

By Michelle Richard on November 9, 2025 Verified by Google

Absolutely our favorite pizza in all of Cape. I have never intentionally ordered a mushroom pizza in my life, yet the Holy Shitake pie here keeps me coming back for more (& introducing new guests each time!) Super pepp is a very close second, and miles ahead of any other pepperoni pizza out there. Chris, the owner, not only hand-tossed our dough (see epic shot), but he is one of the kindest, most generous community servant I know. Alicia, our bartender, was super attentive and made great drinks. She timed our orders perfectly, and seamlessly multitasked the bar and the tables in her area. I highly recommend this place, but it’s also 100% worth noting that the pies are MUCH better in the restaurant than if you order to go. Do yourself a favor…at least for the first experience. And say hi to Chris & Alicia!

By Daryl Jones on November 2, 2025 Verified by Google

Awesome Mellow! This is our 28th Mellow Mushroom location and the food and service was great! The atmosphere was very cool and the owner shared the local inspiration for it. Jenna B. was an amazing host! They made us feel at home and it was a great lunch! We will be back.

By Lauren F on June 19, 2025 Verified by Google

We had a wonderful first experience here! The service was phenomenal. The food was great. We loved the Honey Sriracha chicken wings. We did a half-and-half specialty pizza which is great you can do that because we love variety - one half super pep the other half merry prankster - it could have been cooked a little bit longer but overall the taste was so good. The restaurant was cute inside and out, with putt-putt next door for entertainment. We will be back!!

By Clarissa Garcia on June 3, 2025 Verified by Google

This was our first time here. Our waitress was super friendly. It's always nice when you feel so welcome. Everything was really good. I can't wait to go back. We had appetizers and pizza, and let me not forget about the amazing cookie sundae. So good. For sure, I recommend trying it. Great happy hour prices also from 12-5.