By Tiana Thompson on July 11, 2026 Verified by Google

Don’t sleep on this place. Ordered cheese pizza, chicken bacon ranch, margarita pizza, and fried chicken wings with garlic Parmesan on the side. Every bite was salacious and we’ve already gone back twice. The atmosphere is only for takeout no place to sit and eat. I haven’t made it in time to eat the garlic knots because it’s always sold out but I believe it because the garlic Parmesan is delicious and I can’t wait to have it on the knots.

By Pete Hines on May 16, 2026 Verified by Google

From NYC. I have been out west 25 yrs. Never really am I consistently impressed with NY style out here. I love this place. So blessed it’s right down the road. They cook it long enough and it has that crispy chewy at the same time thing NY pizza is known for.

By Daysha Niles on March 29, 2026 Verified by Google

I’ve been searching for the perfect NY pizzeria in my area and I’ve found it!!! Supremos is spot on to the NY taste, thin crust, perfect undercarriage, not that greasy and not to much cheese!! The front desk guy was so kind to bring me my food across the parking lot as well! I will definitely be back!!!

By James McMenamin on July 23, 2025 Verified by Google

Great NY style thin crust pizza. The low rating reviews make me laugh. This place is legit, have had it several times as it's right down the street from my house and it's been great every....single....time. NJ east coaster who has had my share of pizza, If you're a clown blasting them with a bad review I'm genuinely curios what you think good pizza is. This isn't take n' bake, not PJ's, not the Pie. Not many places in the greater SLC area make pizza this way. "It's delicious! " to quote Rod Farva.

Supremo Pizza!

Very flavorful sauce, great thin crust, dough made in house. 3 years running strong keep it going! How ya do'in.........

By Lacey Clarke on April 14, 2025 Verified by Google

We have been on the search for the perfect thin crust pizza with those crispy little pepperonis, (you know the ones), and our search has come to an end! Supremo serves up amazing New York-style pizza. Honestly the most authentic we’ve found in Utah. We’ve tried the pepperoni, five cheese (personal fave), buffalo, and BBQ chicken — all were delicious.

The flavors are spot on, though the buffalo pizza had a bit more sauce than we expected. We took home the leftovers and threw it in the air fryer the next day and it was even better the second round. 😂 Definitely a go-to spot for quality pizza!

⭐️Food: 10/10
⭐️Service: Great
⭐️Atmosphere: Small, clean space. Parking can be a bit tricky while events are going on next door.
⭐️Value: Definitely worth driving up to for a late night slice. Pizza always comes out HOT and you can conveniently order ahead on their app.