By Hector on September 2, 2026 Verified by Google

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

10/10!! We had such a great experience at Goodfellas Pizza last night. There were only two workers running the night shift, and they absolutely ROCKED it! They were working hard, stayed friendly, and handled everything so well despite being short-staffed. On top of that, the food was AMAZING! Everything was fresh, hot, and delicious. Huge shoutout to those two workers for killing it — they deserve some recognition! I believe their names were Ashley and Rachel. We’ll definitely be back! 🍕❤️

By Katie Prevost on June 7, 2026 Verified by Google

This is a review on the food that was ordered while we were at the speakeasy above the pizzeria.

We ordered a caprese salad and the Vinny pie while upstairs at the speakeasy on a slow Thursday afternoon.

The gentleman who brought us our caprese salad, didn't directly say anything to us, but instead spoke only to the bartender (as he placed the salad in front of us) and told him not to place any more orders for caprese. He seemed inconvenienced by our order and more interested in his smoke break.

We were surprised at the presentation and at the lack of flavor but assumed that the pizza would be amazing! based on what we had read and heard - but were incredibly disappointed.
The pizza was flavorless and Incredibly greasy.

Our impression is that this must be a great location for college students or those who have enjoyed their drinking experience and need some grease to sober them up and don't mind what they are eating.

We were very let down in our experience and the lack of professionalism from the employee who seemed to think that since he was in the speakeasy, he didn't need to be professional.

By Katie Hoover on May 9, 2026 Verified by Google

Goodfellas is the first thing my bestie and I look forward to after a night out!! The pizza is so good and the staff are always the sweetest. SHOUT OUT to my boy Reese last night who took our request for pizza toppings and made the best slices for us, he is a king👑

By The K Green Show on April 4, 2026 Verified by Google

I enjoyed my slice of pizza from Goodfellas on main street. Slice was large, crust was crispy, and the toppings were good. Cool to watch the pizzas being made behind the counter.

By Brandy Johnson on February 9, 2026 Verified by Google

Triple check your order to make sure the site doesn't kick it to a different location. Because of that the pizza I ordered sat for a while which made it have a rubber consistency. The way they wrapped up the sub should be a crime. When taking the sub out of the bag, my son lost his poor meatball all covered in sauce it fell on his lap and then rolled across the floor!