By Julian Alvarez on July 3, 2026 Verified by Google

Love this little bakery. I have driven past this shop many times but I finally stopped in . I got a couple of 4" mini cakes and ended up getting a key lime pie, chocolate chip cookies, blue berry skones and of course their famous cinnamon rolls.
All were the best I have ever had.
Huge hit with the family in town for the holiday too.
If you ever want high quality baked goods then this is the best place on the island.
They open at 0830 AM.

By David K on June 15, 2026 Verified by Google

Wow, we got a variety grab bag from here and we’re so impressed. All the deserts were beautiful and delicious. We will be back soon to try more things. What a pleasant surprise discovering a new business!

By Hannah Lewis on June 15, 2026 Verified by Google

I had two cakes done for my daughter’s birthday.
The absolute creativity and artwork that was incredible and the cake was loved by everyone
It was one of the best cakes I’ve ever seen and I’m a former baker myself
The cake itself was delicious as well

10/10 and I have now found my new bakery for all my cakes

By Jasmine Serrano on June 8, 2026 Verified by Google

Purchased a variety of baked goods a few weeks in a row. Everything was so good. Cake scraps and cupcakes are always perfect. Spongy and moist. Since those were so good, I ordered a cookies and cream birthday cake and it was a hit! Compliments from the whole table. All wanted the name of the bakery for future cake orders.

By Thomas LS on March 13, 2026 Verified by Google

A Will and A Whisk is a delightful locally owned and operated bakery that is new to the area. I tried their brown butter chocolate chip cookie, strawberry crumble cake, and a cinnamon roll. Each and every one was fantastically delicious. The cookie, my god, perfect consistency, satisfyingly chewy but soft enough to almost melt in your mouth. Sadly it was too good to survive the trip home.

Service was friendly and prompt, and each item had a great portion size for the price! While I was there they were decorating a custom cake, something I will be ordering in the near future. All in all I cannot wait to come back to try another baked work of art!