By G W on June 26, 2026 Verified by Google

The Bagel Experience is such a unique little spot. It’s super cute and quaint, but still offers a ton of options. Just know that when they’re sold out, they’re truly sold out, which honestly speaks to how fresh everything is.

They have a huge selection of both breakfast and lunch items, from classic breakfast sandwiches and bagels with different spreads to wraps, salads, deli-style sandwiches, and plenty of other choices. There really is something for everyone.

I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese on a poppy seed bagel. It was straightforward, nothing over-the-top, just a really good, classic breakfast bagel done right.

My partner got the All American, which was essentially an Italian-style deli sandwich on a plain bagel with mayo instead of Italian dressing, and it was delicious. It tasted like a classic deli sandwich with an excellent bagel and plenty of flavor.

We also tried a cinnamon roll that was literally the size of your head. It was very good, although I personally would have loved a little more icing on top. It was slightly dry, but we also ate it later in the day, so that’s not a knock against the bakery. An option for extra icing on the side would really elevate the experience. I highly recommend warming it in the oven for about 10 minutes before eating because it makes it even better.

The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. They felt like genuine local people who truly care about their customers. For how busy they get, they handled the morning rush extremely well.

Beyond the bagels, they offer coffee, sodas, and other drink options, but you can tell that the bagels are the star of the show. I’d definitely love to come back and try some of their different spreads and specialty combinations.

If you’re craving a great breakfast, a quick lunch, or a delicious bagel after a workout or before work, this place is absolutely worth a visit. We will definitely be back.

By L X on May 22, 2026 Verified by Google

Awesome bagel sandwiches. My “go to” is a pork roll, egg & cheese with hash brown on a garlic bagel 🤤 I like that they have featured bagels also. Their French Toast bagel with cream cheese is a nice treat too!

Tip: Get a fresh bagel sandwich and if you want - bagels to go for next day. They have a variety of cream cheese spreads you can purchase. (Recommendation for Bagel Experience: to include expiration dates on the cream cheese)

They operate like a seamless assembly line - each staff working swiftly to keep things moving. It always feels hectic but they don’t appear noticeably stress and they never take it out on their customers!

Cons - charge extra for credit card & tight space. It’s also a gamble to show up because they often sell out/close early.

Definitely a grab and go atmosphere. I think they have the ability to expand! I think they could easily open another/bigger location. (Although, I’m just grateful to have them nearby!) Keep in mind - you’ll likely be waiting outside or trying to squeeze a spot inside.

I have visited Bagel Experience numerous times. Once there was an error with my order and they provided great customer service to resolve it. Another time, I hadn’t noticed the mistake until later - there was some type of wire like material in my Aunt’s sandwich. Otherwise, no issues. Yummy bagel sandwiches!! Definitely recommend!

By Steve Wilson on May 8, 2026 Verified by Google

Hands down the best bagel I have ever had. Great selection. Fast service!

By Jeff on April 22, 2026 Verified by Google

They have quite the operation going on behind the counter! This is not the place to go in not knowing what you want. There was a line out the door.. From the time I got in line, to the time I paid, it was over half an hour. But thats not because they were slow, its just they were SO busy. And everyone was in such good moods even when being slammed.

They had plenty of bagel flavors + homemade cream cheeses. I love how big and consistent the bagels were! Sometimes you go somewhere and the bagels arent consistent in size..
Both bagel sandwiches I got were great and at a reasonable price.

By Lynn on December 20, 2025 Verified by Google

these were the best bagels I have ever tasted. They were incredibly fresh, and every variety I tried was amazing. I’ve also ordered sandwiches from them, and those were just as delicious. The staff is always busy, but they still keep things moving. Prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is lively with that classic, heavy bagel shop smell that hits you as soon as you walk in. Their cream cheese is absolutely the best , rich, flavorful, and the perfect match for their fresh bagels.

By c e on November 15, 2025 Verified by Google

Delicious bagels! They make fantastic breakfast and lunch sandwiches also. Service is always very quick but you have to hurry because they will sell out!

By Donna “Baby Blue Eyes” Miller on November 6, 2025 Verified by Google

A fantastic and well established hot spot! Know what you would like to order at least the day prior to your visit and get there as early as possible to place said order! Otherwise, this place gets so busy they could sell out (of some hot ticket items) by noon! Freshness seems to always be guaranteed! I Highly recommend that once your breakfast order is underway you should then check out their lunch menu items so that your lunch will also not be a disappointment!

By Neelam Favaro on August 9, 2025 Verified by Google

This is a small bagel shop that does bagels right! I've been here about 3 times and the first and third time I have been, they have had ample of bagels. It does run out, so if you want bagels, get there early! The staff is very nice, but being a small shop, it gets hectic and they are doing their best to keep the line moving and getting orders out so be patient! The cream cheeses are super flavorful and yummy! Overall, great place!

By Michelle Gatpo on February 27, 2024 Verified by Google

Can’t get any more authentic than this New York style deli and bakery! We ordered freshly baked bagels, a super tasty cannoli made with actual ricotta, and a chocolate cake Boston cream bomb dessert. Amazing location- right next to Catholic Church to stop by after mass. Thank you for being so good!