By Minjae Chris Kim on October 11, 2026 Verified by Google

Pizza was really good. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but respectable. Crust was nice and chewy but lacked any flavour. The doughnuts were out of this world though. The best doughnuts I have ever had. Who would have thought that this place serving pizza would have such amazing doughnuts. The apple fritters deserve some kind of award. Come for the pizza, stay for the apple fritters. I didn't even take a photo because they were eaten so fast.

By Annie Dulnuan on August 7, 2026 Verified by Google

If you love sourdough this place is for you. First time trying sourdough doughnuts and wow. The dough is so fluffy. Will definitely be coming back for more doughnuts. I have to try their pizza next the time I pass by Hamilton. The strawberry matcha was good but I had better. There is a few seating area inside but it gets full fast so come early.

By Melanie Singh on July 19, 2026 Verified by Google

What a great little find! Café Baffico is small, cozy, and full of charm. We came for the sourdough pizza and couldn't resist trying one of their unique doughnuts—the Caramel Apple Fritter—and it was incredible. We also had the Margherita pizza, the Roni Supreme pizza, and a latte, and everything was absolutely delicious. We enjoyed the coffee so much that we couldn't leave without a bag of their beans. The service was warm, friendly, and genuinely welcoming. It's absolutely worth the drive to Hamilton, and we'll definitely be back.

By Hou Claire on June 27, 2026 Verified by Google

These donuts are so cute! I couldn't resist eating two. The chocolate and cherry flavor was amazing. Pistachio and orange flavor is new flavor, however the pistachio taste wasn't very strong. It was more like an orange donut. But It still good. Next time, I hope to try their feature pizza! Pizzas are only available from 12 PM onwards.

By Richard Daniel on June 6, 2026 Verified by Google

Tucked away in a Hamilton hamlet, Cafe Baffico is a gem. Beautiful interior design coupled with friendly service and delicious food, this place is a must-visit.

The line of customers is continuous which at times can disrupt your dining experience, but they are doing the best with be square footage they have, and it's quiantness adds to its unique environment.

The sourdough cinnamon bun was our favourite, but each menu item was great! Tip: make sure you don't just go for donuts, get a slice of pizza at least - sooooo good! The drip coffee and homemade hibiscus iced tea was flavourful as well.

Definitely worth the drive from St. Catharines. We will be back!