By Susan Keeble on July 23, 2026 Verified by Google

This was our first order with People’s Choice Pizza and we could not have been more pleased. LOVED the NY style pizza and the boneless wings were really good. It was so easy to order on line and pick up. This will be our new “go-to” place.

By Marilyn Sales on July 18, 2026 Verified by Google

Andi assisted me with my order and was an absolute gem. Service and food was exceptional! We ordered the XL Piggly Wiggly pizza and fried pickles. DELICIOUS! I wish we lived closer or they were closer to us. We would definitely be a repeat customer.

By Jason Tuttle on May 9, 2026 Verified by Google

This is the first time I have ordered from People's Choice in over 5 years and I'm honestly not sure why I stopped. They've always had great food/pizzas. Tonight, we ordered a Choice pizza and a Lasagna pizza. They were bought great. Plus, the upgrades to the website made the experience so much better than their competitors. They were also were great about keeping us updated. I will definitely start ordering from them again.

By P. 1992 on May 6, 2026 Verified by Google

First time we came here for wings, pizza, and subs, it was super amazing. We were really impressed. The second time though was a completely different experience.

The sub felt plain with barely anything on it and wet, the pizza did not have much flavor or toppings, and the fries were soggy and felt like they were dipped in water. Overall it did not feel worth the $55 we spent that time.

I think It this place can be a big bit hit or miss depending on who is making your food, which makes it hard to know if your time and money will be worth it.

I would recommend coming when the young woman is managing, as that is when we had the best experience with our supper.

I'll be very frank, do not come if the man is there.

By Alston Green on November 3, 2025 Verified by Google

My first time coming here in about a year. I asked about the Philly cheesesteak, and the young said that it was her favorite, and that I should try the pizza. It did not disappoint, 10 out 10. Highly recommended.