By Nick Burkert on August 20, 2026 Verified by Google

Incredible anniversary dinner!

Exceptional steaks and pasta, tasty drinks, and prompt, professional service. They even surprised us with complimentary champagne for our anniversary, which was a fantastic touch. Baked potato and broccolini was very good. Shrimp cocktail was delicious

Pricing is very reasonable for an upscale steakhouse, though parking can be challenging downtown. The only minor downside was the cheesecake, which was a bit dry.

Still easily a 5-star experience overall!

By Joshua Chamberlain on July 29, 2026 Verified by Google

We checked out J. Gilbert's while in the city. Nice looking place, street parking can be a challenge. Good eats with good service. Pretty good tasting steak. Not a fan of their bread.

By F'burg Foodie on June 15, 2026 Verified by Google

After three nights in Omaha and having steak each night, I wanted something different this evening for dinner, so I wanted to come here. I knew that J. Gilberts serves more than just steaks, as I’ve been to the one in Tysons Corner and loved that one.

There were four of us who came here for dinner… We started with cocktails, which took an odd amount of time to arrive at the table – we got half and then waited about 10 minutes for the other two to show up. Not sure what happened here, but those who got their drinks waited so we could all drink together and this made that moment a little off.

We started with their Pretzel Crusted Onion Rings – WOW!! These things were HUGE!!! The thickest and biggest onion rings I’ve ever seen or had and they were tasty! The pretzel crust was very tasty too.

I opted for their blackened chicken rigatoni for dinner. It was decent, but on the bland site. The roasted red pepper cream was interesting looking, but a scoop of blandness too. Overall I did like the flavor of the chicken and the sauce/texture was nice.

This visit was decent, but slight delays in service and food being on the bland side makes me want to give it 4 instead of 5 stars.

By elena guerrero on March 2, 2026 Verified by Google

I had such a great experience at J. Gilbert’s, and I genuinely have to shout out Melissa, the manager. From the moment we walked in, she carried herself with so much professionalism and warmth. You can tell she truly cares about both the guests and her team. She was attentive without hovering, checked in at the perfect times, and made sure everything at our table was exactly how it should be.

What really stood out was how calm and confident she was while still being so kind and personable. She handled everything smoothly and made us feel valued, not just like another table. It’s rare to see management that’s this involved and intentional about creating a great atmosphere. Because of Melissa, our experience went from good to amazing. J. Gilbert’s is lucky to have her leading — she sets the standard for what hospitality should feel like.

By Claudia Kenyon on February 16, 2026 Verified by Google

Fantastic experiences every time we visit. We visit multiple times a year for the last five years and it’s a favorite for my husband and I. We got engaged here and they hosted us for both our engagement photos and wedding dinner. Nothing short of professionalism, comfort and great taste. The Prix Fixe is such a good menu, we cannot visit and go without our Maryland crab bisque and the drinks just are phenomenal. They have an entrance connected to the Marriott for convenience with a sky walk that suits all weather. Special shout out to Gina, our server the last three times we’ve visited, she’s so incredibly attentive, friendly and has a great eye for detail. We’ve visited around major holidays Valentine’s Day and New Years and she’s been such a delight in making sure the experience was perfection. It’s a great spot for date nights, somewhere special to take family visiting from out of town or during a night out with friends given it’s so close to so many entertainment options.