Cold Stone Creamery

Cold Stone Creamery Verified by Yext

3.1

(36 Reviews)

Write a Review

Listed In: Ice Cream and Frozen Desserts Place, Pastries and Desserts Place, Bakeries and Desserts

Your local Cold Stone Creamery in Massapequa, NY is the ultimate ice cream shop offering Create Your Own Creations™ mixed on a granite slab, custom ice cream cakes for any occasion, and rich, creamy milkshakes. Indulge in endless flavors, mix-ins, and sweet treats made fresh just for you. Get a… Read more

3.1

36 Reviews

Write a Review
jennifer ahrens

By jennifer ahrens on June 3, 2026 Verified by Google

0 stars for a terrible customer service experience . Girl with an attitude chomping gum. No offer to help as I stood at counter. There was only one other customer in the store. Will not go back again.

Nick V

By Nick V on November 18, 2025 Verified by Google

I ordered 4 cups online for pick up. All 4 were made wrong. I tried calling multiple times and they refused to answer the phone.
The peanut butter cup was made with vanilla instead of chocolate and the birthday cake remix was made with sweet cream instead of the cake batter. The portions were VASTLY different for each cup and they were all the largest size.

Absolute rip off, someone better refund me.

Rashid Mannan

By Rashid Mannan on June 26, 2025 Verified by Google

I usually love Cold Stone, but it’s been a long time since I’ve had their ice cream. The weather was really hot, so the wife and I thought it’d be the perfect time to have some ice cream.

I ordered the Coffee Lovers Only ice cream. It had already melted by the time the staff handed it to me. Too bad, because other than the melted ice cream, the Heath Bar and almonds pieces tasted really good.

Other customers were complaining once they got their ice cream, and the staff replied that their machine was broken. I wish they would have mentioned that before I ordered my ice cream

Wittytwiggy

By Wittytwiggy on December 9, 2024 Verified by Google

Thank you to Mike W. for creating the most fun experience I've ever had ordering at a Cold Stone (and for dealing with my mother's indecisiveness with patience and grace :p)

We came in pretty late at night to try the new chocolate malt flavor. My mom and I struck up a conversation with Mike and ended up trying a few more flavors, and Mike took it upon himself to make some pretty phenomenal custom creations. Mango puree and French vanilla is a heavenly combination and definitely going to become a regular order. Best customer service I've ever had!!

mr product

By mr product on August 25, 2024 Verified by Google

Worst customer service ever. Only 2 employees working, one of them with curly hair moving like a snail. No care for the customers especially the guy with curly hair there are people waiting in line and he’s eating ice cream while making online orders.
This location needs to have faster employees.

Showing the overall rating from Google. Load more reviews to see individual Google reviews.

Powered by Opio

Cold Stone Creamery 3.1 out of 5.0 based on 36 user reviews.

Cold Stone Creamery
25 Hicksville Rd, Massapequa, NY
Get Directions

Additional Business Details

Business Hours

M-Su 11am-11:45pm

Listing data provided by Yext

Similar Businesses See All

Red Mango

Red Mango

1526 Union Trnpk, Flr Grd, New Hyde Park, NY (20 Km Away)

4.0

(270 Reviews)

Chip City

Chip City

951 Franklin Ave, Garden City, NY (15 Km Away)

4.7

(255 Reviews)

Chip City

Chip City

(23 Km Away)

4.9

(36 Reviews)

Business Claimed Update your Business

Report Incorrect Data Make an Update