By John Prescod on October 25, 2025 Verified by Google

The first thing you notice everytime you walk in is the smell. It is absolutely amazing. It also immediately makes you want to purchase items. The biggest challenge is figuring out what you want.

The store is very colorful. For a most size storefront, there is a large selection of items. Upon entering you are greeted by a delicious selection of fudge. Behind that area is the table where they make fresh caramel coated popcorn and peanuts a la Cracker Jacks and Fiddle Faddle.

Beyond that, you can choose from everything from candied apples, to truffles (including Dubai chocolate), to dipped marshmallows and pretzels. They also sell real good ice cream and ice cream cakes.

Being that we're 2 weeks away from Halloween, they also offer themed confections. There's your standard candy corn and wrapped chocolates. They also have Halloween themed and decorated candy apples (see the mummy). You can either take the apples intact or have them cut it into pieces for you.

By Kelsey Parker on April 26, 2025 Verified by Google

My husband and I constantly find ourselves coming back here anytime we want a sweet treat! Their caramel apples are AMAZING as are their gummy bears that nearly got me through my entire pregnancy.

I just got two ice cream cakes from them for my husband’s birthday and they far surpass any other ice cream cake out there! The customer service has always been exceptional and welcoming even with my high energy toddler in tow.

Highly recommend you try them!

By NBaez on January 30, 2025 Verified by Google

Our first time here was a phenomenal experience, to say the least. Sunny made our first time here a very pleasurable one. She was attentive, funny, kind, honest, and so full of joy that she made me want to buy everything there. Now, the chocolate was really good, and the peanut brittle was phenomenal 👌🏼 10/10 I would come back.

By Hi Im A Flying Person on December 19, 2024 Verified by Google

I came here a few months ago with my boyfriend. We tried some of the ice cream samples and they were good. He got a milkshake and we both liked it. It was the perfect consistency. The employees were nice. There’s not really much to say. But, this place smells absolutely heavenly. I love it. We’ve only been here once but when we come back to Blue Back Square we will definitely stop by again.

By DS Will on May 15, 2023 Verified by Google

I’ve gone 3 times in 24 hours, my friends, family and I are absolutely loving it! The toasted coconut ice cream with a chocolate base is ridiculously good! And so is Kat!! Must go!